Smokefree Outdoor Air

As people enjoy the health benefits of smokefree air indoors, it is only natural to want to enjoy those same benefits in outdoor areas, especially those where people gather or work and have high levels of exposure.

In response to increased public demand and new scientific information on the health hazards in close-quarter outdoor areas, many communities with smokefree indoor air laws have expanded, or are considering expanding, smokefree protections to some outdoor public places.

These areas include outdoor workplaces, restaurant and bar patios, service lines, transit waiting areas, public events like county fairs and farmer's markets, as well as parks, beaches, and recreation areas.

It's important for communities to continue focusing on achieving smokefree air for indoor public places and workplaces first, because that is where the majority people are still most exposed to secondhand smoke. Public demand and support for working on outdoor areas often increases once communities are smokefree indoors.

View ANR Foundation's quarterly lists of Smokefree Outdoor Areas

 

 

 

Secondhand Smoke Exposure Outdoors

Scientific research on outdoor exposure to secondhand smoke has grown in recent years.

In 2005, the California Air Resources Board (ARB) released a report that evaluated the first-ever monitoring of the level of outdoor exposure to secondhand smoke on the health of California residents. Based on the conclusions of this report, the ARB adopted a regulatory amendment that identified secondhand smoke as a toxic air contaminant - an outdoor air pollutant that may cause or contribute to an increase in deaths or in serious illness, or which may pose a present or potential hazard to human health.

In 2007, Stanford University researchers published an in-depth study of outdoor secondhand smoke levels. The primary finding is that secondhand smoke exposure levels can be significant near an active smoker.

In 2009, a study published in Preventive Medicine looked at how common smoking is on bar patios in Toronto, Canada, and how much particulate matter was in the air, in order to assess whether smokefree bar laws provide adequate protection to bar workers. The study concluded that smokefree bar laws do not provide workers with adequate protection from SHS if smoking is allowed on adjacent patios.

This study provides compelling evidence that communities should continue addressing secondhand smoke exposure beyond indoor worksites, especially to areas adjacent to indoor workplaces.

Outdoor Dining Areas

Patio areas of restaurants and bars are both workplaces and areas where people are closely congregated, so these venues are frequently addressed in smokefree efforts. People outdoors that are near secondhand smoke for extended periods of time, such as wait staff or diners on patios, can be exposed at levels that exceed the EPA limit on fine particulate matter pollution.

Patio dining areas are outdoor workplaces that are particularly important areas to address, since nonsmokers and smokers are in close proximity and it is often not easy to move away from smoke when working in these areas or patronizing these businesses. The employees who often have to work in both the smokefree indoor areas of the establishment and the patios cannot escape the smoke when working their outdoor tables.

Numerous cities -- including Beverly Hills, CA; Hawaii County, HI, Alton, TX; Starkville, MS; and Hesston, KS - plus Maine, Iowa, and Hawaii, have enacted smokefree laws for outdoor patio areas of restaurants with some provisions including bar patios too.

In Santa Monica, CA, a Fresh Air Dining smokefree dining campaign encouraged restaurants to voluntarily make their outdoor dining areas smokefree and publicized those restaurants that make a smokefree commitment. Later, the city adopted a law to bring smokefree air to all outdoor dining areas of restaurants and bars.

Other Outdoor Workplaces

The Canadian bar study provides compelling evidence that communities should continue addressing secondhand smoke exposure beyond indoor worksites, especially to areas adjacent to indoor workplaces.

Boston, Massachusetts, adopted a law in 2008 that requires that outdoor workplaces adjacent to indoor workplaces to be smokefree. The city recognized that employees in outdoor worksites who suffer from secondhand smoke exposure deserve the same health protections as people in indoor worksites.

Entryways

More than 1,136 communities and numerous states have enacted smokefree entryway provisions that help keep smoke from drifting indoors.

Smokefree entryway, or "reasonable distance," laws require that no smoking occur within a certain distance (usually 15-25 feet) of doorways, operable windows, and air intake vents of smokefree buildings. These policies help prevent secondhand smoke from drifting back into the building. The policies also allow employees and customers to access the building without walking through clouds of smoke.

Parks and Beaches

Secondhand smoke exposure is just one reason why communities and states are adopting smokefree park and beach laws. There are also strong environmental reasons for expanding smokefree policies to these outdoor venues.

The trash created by cigarette butts tossed on the ground is a significant environmental problem. Cigarette butts are a leading source of pollution in parks and beaches. The butts are full of the same chemicals and toxins as the cigarettes themselves, plus the filters are made from cellulose acetate, a plastic that can break into tiny pieces, but will never biodegrade or disappear. They are hazardous and highly toxic to fish, birds, other wildlife, plus pets and young children if they are ingested. Butts tossed on sidewalks often end up in our waterways and washed back onto beaches.

Fire danger is also a compelling environmental and safety reason why smoking is not allowed on beaches and in parks. In 2007, a discarded cigarette caused a massive fire that burned one quarter of Los Angeles' 4,210 acre Griffith Park. The fire provided motivation for the city of Los Angeles to adopt a law requiring all city parks to be smokefree.

In many communities, smokefree air coalitions have teamed up with environmental organizations to work together on smokefree park and beach efforts due to their common interests of keeping these recreation areas and natural spaces clean, healthy, and safe for all to enjoy.

In Southern California, some coalitions working on smokefree beaches developed a key partnership with the SurfRider Foundation, which focuses on coastal environmental issues.

Many beachfront tourist destinations have smokefree beaches. Communities along the New Jersey shore led the way and have been adopting smokefree beach laws since 2001. In California, numerous beaches from San Diego to Los Angeles are smokefree due to locally adopted policies. In 2009, Maine adopted a smokefree law for beaches, parks, playgrounds and other areas of state parks. The law was adopted for both public health and environmental reasons, to create public spaces that are healthier and safer for both people and the environment.

 

Examples of Smokefree Signs for Outdoor Areas
Click on thumbnails to view full-size images


No smoking on esplanade

No smoking in this
commercial zone

No smoking within the park
No fumar dentro del parque

Smell flowers, not smoke

Smoking prohibited
in tot play areas

 

Related Research | News
Fu, M.; Martínez-Sánchez, J.M.; Galán, I.; Pérez-Ríos, M.; Sureda, X.; López, M.J.; Schiaffino, A.; Moncada, A.; Montes, A.;, Nebot, M.; Fernández, E., "Variability in the correlation between nicotine and PM2.5 as airborne markers of second-hand smoke exposure," Environmental Research [Epub ahead of print], October 28, 2013.
Potera, C., "Outdoor smoking areas: eoes the science support a ban?," Environmental Health Perspectives 121(7): a229, July 1, 2013.
Sureda, X.; Fernandez, E.; Lopez, M.J.; Nebot, M., "Second-hand tobacco smoke exposure in open and semi-open settings: a systematic review," Envirionmental Health Perspectives 121(7): 766-773, July 2013.
Bayer, R.; Bachynski, K.E., "Analysis and commentary: banning smoking in parks and on beaches: science, policy, and the politics of denormalization," Health Affairs 32(7): 1291-1298, July 2013.
Collins, D.; Parsons, M.; Zinyemba, C., "Air quality at outdoor community events: findings from fine particulate (PM) sampling at festivals in Edmonton, Alberta," International Journal of Environmental Health Research [Epub ahead of print], July 1, 2013.
Acevedo-Bolton, V.; Ott, W.R.; Cheng, K.C.; Jiang, R.T.; Klepeis, N.E.; Hildemann, L.M. "Controlled experiments measuring personal exposure to PM in close proximity to cigarette smoking," Indoor Air [Epub ahead of print], June 29, 2013.
Okoli, C.; Johnson, A.; Pederson, A.; Adkins, S.; Rice, W., "Changes in smoking behaviours following a smokefree legislation in parks and on beaches: an observational study," BMJ Open [Epub ahead of print], June 20, 2013.
Yamato, H.; Mori, N.; Horie, R.; Garcon, L.; Taniguchi, M.; Armada, F., "Designated smoking areas in streets where outdoor smoking is banned," Kobe Journal of Medical Sciences 59(3): E93-E105, June 17, 2013.
Licht, A.S.; Hyland, A.; Travers, M.J.; Chapman, S., "Secondhand smoke exposure levels in outdoor hospitality venues: a qualitative and quantitative review of the research literature," Tobacco Control 22(3): 172-179, May 2013.
Lopez, M.J.; Fernandez, E.; Perez-Rios, M.; Martinez-Sanchez, J.M.; Schiaffino, A.; Galan, I.; Moncada, A.; Fu, M.; Montes, A.; Salto, E.; Nebot, M., "Impact of the 2011 Spanish smoking ban in hospitality venues: indoor secondhand smoke exposure and influence of outdoor smoking," Nicotine and Tobacco Research 15(5): 992-996, May 2013.
Okoli, C.T.; Pederson, A.; Rice, W., "Support for a smoke-free bylaw in parks and on beaches," Health Policy [Epub ahead of print], April 17, 2013.
Gini, M.; Lianou, M.; Chalbot, M.C.; Kotronarou, A.; Kavouras, I.G.; Helmis, C.G., "Quantification of environmental tobacco smoke contribution on outdoor particulate aliphatic and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons," Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 64(3): 347-356, April 2013.
Thomson, G.; Russell, M.; Jenkin, G.; Patel, V.; Wilson, N., "Informing outdoor smokefree policy: methods for measuring the proportion of people smoking in outdoor public areas," Health and Place 20C: 19-24, December 7, 2012.
Sureda, X.; Martinez-Sanchez, J.M.; Lopez, M.J.; Fu, M.; Aguero, F.; Salto, E.; Nebot, M.; Fernandez, E., "Secondhand smoke levels in public building main entrances: outdoor and indoor PM2.5 assessment," Tobacco Control 21(6): 543-548, November 1, 2012.
Patel, V.; Thomson, G.; Wilson, N., "Smoking increases air pollution levels in city streets: observational and fine particulate data," Health & Place 18(5): 1202-1205, September 5, 2012.
Russell, M.; Wilson, N.; Thomson, G., "Health and nuisance impacts from outdoor smoking on public transport users: data from Auckland and Wellington," New Zealand Medical Journal 88-91, August 24, 2012.
Lopez, M.J.; Fernandez, E.; Gorini, G.; Moshammer, H.; Polanska, K.; Clancy, L.; Dautzenberg, B.; Delrieu, A.; Invernizzi, G.; Munoz, G.; Precioso, J.; Ruprecht, A.; Stansty, P.; Hanke, W.; Nebot, M., "Exposure to secondhand smoke in terraces and other outdoor areas of hospitality venues in eight European countries," PLoS One 7(8): e42130, August 2012.
Shoe, E., "Tobacco-free parks: maximizing health impact in built environment planning," North Carolina Medical Journal 73(4): 287-288, July 2012.
St. Helen, G.; Bernert, J.T.; Hall, D.B.; Sosnoff, C.S.; Xia, Y.; Balmes, J.R.; Vena, J.E.; Wang, J.S.; Holland, N.T.; Naeher, L.P., "Exposure to secondhand smoke outside of a bar and a restaurant and tobacco exposure biomarkers in non-smokers," Environmental Health Perspectives [Epub ahead of print], April 6, 2012.
Gallus, S.; Rosato, V.; Zuccaro, P.; Pacifici, R.; Colombo, P.; Manzari, M.; La Vecchia, C., "Attitudes towards the extension of smoking restrictions to selected outdoor areas in Italy," Tobacco Control 21(1): 59-62, January 2012.
Ariza, E.; Leatherman, S.P., "No-smoking policies and their outcomes on U.S. beaches," Journal of Coastal Research 28(1A Supplement): 143–147, 2012.
Edward, R.; Wilson, N., "Smoking outdoors at pubs and bars: is it a problem? An air quality study," Journal of the New Zealand Medical Association [Epub ahead of print], December 16, 2011.
St. Helen, G.; Hall, D.B.; Kudon, L.H.; Baptiste, S.; Ferguson, S.; Green, T.; Naeher, L.R.; Pearce, J., "Particulate matter (PM2.5) and carbon monoxide from secondhand smoke outside bars and restaurants in downtown Athens, Georgia," Journal of Environmental Health 74(3): 8-17, October 2011.
Nebot, M.; Sureda, X.; Martinez-Sanchez, J.M.; Lopez, M.J.; Fu, M.; Aguero, F.; Salto, E., "Secondhand smoke levels in public building main entrances: outdoor and indoor PM2.5 assessment," Tobacco Control [Epub ahead of print], September 28, 2011.
Satterland, T.D.; Cassady, D.; Treiber, J.; Lemp, C., "Strategies implemented by 20 local tobacco control agencies to promote smoke-free recreation areas, California, 2004-2007," Preventing Chronic Disease 8(5): A111 , September 2011.
Colgrove, J.; Bayer, R.; Bachynski, K.E., "Nowhere left to hide? The banishment of smoking from public spaces," New England Journal of Medicine, May 25, 2011.
Kaufman, P.; Zhang, B.; Bondy, S.J.; Klepeis, N.; Ferrence, R., "Not just 'a few wisps': real-time measurement of tobacco smoke at entrances to office buildings," Tobacco Control 20(3): 212-218, May 2011.
Karabela, M.; Vardavas, C.I.; Tzatzarakis, M.; Tsatsakis, A.; Dockery, D.; Connolly, G.N.; Behrakis, P., "The relationship between venue indoor air quality and urinary cotinine levels among semiopen-air cafe employees: what factors determine the level of exposure?," Journal of Aerosol Medicine and Pulmonary Drug Delivery, [Epub ahead of print], October 20, 2010.
Stafford, J.; Daube, M.; Franklin, P., "Second hand smoke in alfresco areas," Health Promotion Journal of Australia 21(2): 99-105, August 2010.
Kaufman, P.; Griffin, K.; Perkins, N.; Ferrence, R.; Cohen, J., "Smoking in urban outdoor public places: behaviour, experiences, and implications for public health," Health Place [Epub ahead of print], June 8, 2010.
Brennan, E.; Cameron, M.; Warne, C.; Durkin, S.; Borland, R.; Travers, M.J.; Hyland, A.; Wakefield, M.A., "Secondhand smoke drift: examining the influence of indoor smoking bans on indoor and outdoor air quality at pubs and bars," Nicotine & Tobacco Research 12(3): 271-277, March 2010.
Sureda, X.; Fu, M.; Lopez, M.L.; Martínez-Sanchez, J.M.; Carabasa, E.; Salto, E.; Martinez, C.; Nebot, M.; Fernandez, E., "Second-hand smoke in hospitals in Catalonia (2009): a cross-sectional study measuring PM2.5 and vapor-phase nicotine," Environmental Research [Epub ahead of print], 2010.
Hall, J.C.; Bernert, J.T.; Hall, D.B.; St Helen, G.; Kudon, L.H.; Naeher, L.P., "Assessment of exposure to secondhand smoke at outdoor bars and family restaurants in Athens, Georgia, using salivary cotinine," Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene 6(11): 698-704, November 2009.
Cameron, M.; Brennan, E.; Durkin, S.J.; Borland, R.; Travers, M.J.; Hyland, A.; Spittal, M.J.; Wakefield, M.A., "Secondhand smoke exposure (PM2.5) in outdoor dining areas and its correlates," Tobacco Control [Epub ahead of print], October 21, 2009.
Zhang, B.; Bondy, S.; Ferrence, R., "Do indoor smoke-free laws provide bar workers with adequate protection from secondhand smoke?," Preventive Medicine [Epub ahead of print], July 6, 2009.
Klepeis, N.E.; Ott, W.R.; Switzer, P., "Real-time measurement of outdoor tobacco smoke particles," Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association 57: 522-534, 2007.
California Air Resources Board, "Proposed identification of environmental tobacco smoke as a toxic air contaminant," Sacramento, CA: California Environmental Protection Agency (Cal-EPA), September 29, 2005.

Smoke-free park policies slow to catch on: study
Reuters - February 18, 2014

(Reuters Health) - Bans on smoking in public parks are still fairly rare in the United States, despite more than half of states having indoor smoking restrictions, researchers say.

Anti-smoking battle moves outdoors; bans increase
The Big Story August 8, 2013

ATLANTA (AP) First it was bars, restaurants and office buildings. Now the front lines of the "No Smoking" battle have moved outdoors. City parks, public beaches, college campuses and other outdoor venues across the country are putting up signs telling smokers they can't light up. Outdoor smoking bans have nearly doubled in the last five years, with the tally now at nearly 2,600 and more are in the works.

Have pub beer gardens now become smoking gardens?
BBC News August 7, 2013

Indoor smoking bans across the UK have pushed tobacco users into areas outside bars and pubs. Are these now no-go areas for non-smokers in the summer? Certainly, smoking bans have not always come to a halt at the door of the bar or cafe. According to the American Nonsmokers' Rights Foundation, there are bans on outdoor smoking in over 840 parks and 150 beaches and the US.

Harmful levels of second-hand smoke found on Montreal patios
Quebec anti-tobacco advocates push for smoking ban on outdoor patios
CBCNews Health - August 3, 2013

Anti-tobacco advocates are using a new study to make the case for a smoking ban on bar and restaurant patios. A researcher at Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, Maryland found harmful levels of second-hand smoke in a survey of Montreal bar patios. The study found that a single lit cigarette could create air quality levels comparable to a smoggy day in Los Angeles. Professor Ryan Kennedy, who conducted the study, says the tests suggests second-hand smoke can be harmful outdoors, even on a windy day.

Legislators Applaud NY Playground Smoking Ban
Patch.com - July 15, 2013

While most may think of playgrounds as a safe place, some believe they can be made dangerous when children are forced to inhale secondhand smoke. Thats why New York State Legislators and health advocates are praising Gov. Andrew Cuomo for approving a bill that would ban smoking on public playgrounds.

Cuomo signs law to ban playground smoking
13WHAM-TV - July 15, 2013

Andrew Cuomo has signed a new law to ban smoking at outdoor ... They note that the state has recently banned smoking on train platforms, and that New York ...

Smoking bans at Honolulu parks and bus stops approved
Hawaii News Now - July 11, 2013

HONOLULU (HawaiiNewsNow) - The Honolulu City Council is sending a strong message against smoking. The nine members unanimously approved two measures that bans lighting up at all bus stops and city parks, beaches, athletic fields and facilities.

Council OKs smoking ban at city parks, bus stops
Honolulu Star-Advertiser - July 10, 2013

Smoking will be banned at all city parks, beaches and bus stops under bills passed ... for public education and time for the city to put up signage about the bans. Testimony was split for Bill 25, banning smoking at Oahu's 293 city-owned parks ...

Honolulu City Council approves park smoking ban
Thegardenisland.com - July 10, 2013

HONOLULU (AP) The Honolulu City Council is moving to ban smoking at city parks, beaches and bus stops. The council passed two bills covering the bans on Wednesday. Mayor Kirk Caldwell is expected to sign the measures.

Smokers Lighting Up Next to Entrances Pollute Venue Air Quality ...
Counsel & Heal-June 14, 2013

"I understand banning people from smoking in hospitals, but I think it's excessive not ... Researchers analyzed the effects of the 2011 Spanish smoking ban in ...

Honolulu Mayor bans smoking at Oahu's beaches and parks
Hawaii Reporter - April 8, 2013

Honolulu Mayor Kirk Caldwell today signed a bill that would ban smoking at Oahu's Kapiolani Park, Kuhio Beach Park, the beach side of Ala Moana Regional Park, Sandy Beach Park, Duke Kahanamoku Beach Park, Kapiolani Beach Park and Kapiolani Park Beach Center.

Mayor signs smoking ban at certain beaches into law
Hawaii News Now - April 8, 2013

HONOLULU (HawaiiNewsNow) - A new law is designed to snuff out smoking at several beaches and parks on Oahu. The restrictions started on April 8, but police are focusing on education instead of enforcement. Honolulu Mayor Kirk Caldwell signed Bill 72 into law to expand the city's smoking ban. Michael Zehner testified against the measure as part of the Hawaii Smokers Alliance. He is upset that people won't be allowed to light up in certain spots. …

Caldwell signs Waikiki beach smoking ban into law
Pacific Business News (Honolulu) - April 8, 2013

Honolulu Mayor Kirk Caldwell on Monday signed into a law a bill that bans smoking at Waikiki Beach and other popular Oahu beaches. …

Honolulu mayor bans smoking on some beaches
Thegardenisland.com - April 9, 2013

HONOLULU (AP) ­ Hawaii visitors and residents who smoke cigarettes will have to put them out before stepping foot on some of Honolulu's sandy beaches. …

Smoking banned within Camden Yards stadiums
CBS Local - February 26, 2013

The Maryland Stadium Authority will prohibit smoking inside stadiums at the Camden Yards Sports Complex. A spokesman for the authority said Monday that the rule will take effect March 4 and will apply to all games and events held within Oriole Park at Camden Yards and M&T Bank Stadium. …

Maryland Stadium Authority bans smoking in all areas of Camden Yards, M&T Bank Stadium
Smokers had been able to light up in designated areas; new policy follows rule at majority of pro stadiums
Baltimore Sun – February 25, 2013

Coleen Deems sat down after every Ravens season and wrote a letter to the team, asking it to ban smoking at the stadium. This year, when her 10-year-old grandson looked up and said, “I have to hold my breath,” while walking past a designated smoking area at M&T Bank Stadium, the 11-year season-ticket holder became more determined and considered tracking down the personal email address of team owner Steve Bisciotti.

Supes Vote To Ban Smoking At Street Fairs
The San Francisco Appeal-January 16, 2013

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors today gave unanimous initial approval to two pieces of legislation addressing smoking in the city.

San Francisco expands smoking restrictions to include outdoor ...
San Francisco Examiner-January 15, 2013

The Board of Supervisors passed two new smoking restrictions Tuesday, joining ... a law banning smoking at outdoor public events and another requiring landlords to ... banned smoking altogether in apartments, and a similar ban was passed last year ... Mar said he crafted the smoking ban for public events with the help of ...

Charleston approves outdoor smoking ban for streets and sidewalks in the hospital district
Charleston Post Courier (subscription) - January 8, 2013

In a decision reached by a single vote, Charleston City Council agreed tonight to ban smoking on public streets and sidewalks in the city’s hospital district. The ban, which takes effect March 1, is the region’s first prohibition on outdoor smoking in an urban center, and covers most of the area on and between Bee and Calhoun streets, Courtney Drive, and Rutledge Avenue in downtown Charleston. …

Outdoor Smoking Bans: Impossible to Enforce, or Inevitable?
The Atlantic Cities - December 10, 2012

For 48 percent of the U.S. population [PDF], and in 30 of the country's 50 largest cities, lighting up in restaurants, bars, and offices is not only banned, it's a fading memory, as distant as typewriters and rotary phones. It has not been the same story on the next frontier of smoking bans, those that seek to stop people from lighting up outdoors. Over a thousand U.S. cities and counties (and several states) have some type of smoke-free law indoors [PDF], and hundreds more have laws regulating smoking in public parks [PDF]. But amid the endless variety ­ no two jurisdictions, it seems, have quite the same laws ­ only a handful of places have banned smoking outright in outdoor public space. ...

EDITORIAL: Make parks smoke-free
The Register-Guard - October 2, 2012

Alicia Hays, director of health and human services for Lane County, has gotten out in front of her bosses on the Board of Commissioners by proposing a ban on smoking on all county property, including in parks. Most of the commissioners either oppose such a ban or would rather talk about other issues. But Hays is on the right track, and board members should understand that implementing her idea would be easier than it seems. …

San Rafael officials approve tough new smoking rules
Marin (CA) Independent Journal - October 2, 2012

San Rafael officials approved the county's toughest anti-tobacco ordinance to date on Monday, banning smoking from all apartments and condominiums, in addition to parks, bus stops, restaurant patios and many other outdoor spaces. …

Even Outside, Harmful Smoke Spreads
Wall Street Journal - August 13, 2012

Few studies have looked at the risks of breathing second-hand smoke ... Ga., on patios outside a family restaurant and a bar where smoking was permitted, and ...

Scientists Evaluate Attitudes Toward Outdoor Smoking Ban
RedOrbit - August 13, 2012

Fifty-seven percent of patients who were smokers also favored the ban. The study ... "Research on the effects of smoking bans on employees is scarce, however. ...

Smoking on footpaths increases hazardous air pollutants
HealthCanal.com - July 9, 2012

Other likely benefits of smokefree streets would be decreased street cleaning costs from less cigarette butt litter, a better public image for a city, the reduction of ...

Smoking in streets can trigger lung cancer - study
TVNZ - July 9, 2012

Wellington City sports parks and playgrounds are to become smokefree areas, as the Council moves to support the Government's goal of making New Zealand ...

Sonoma County Snuffs Out Patio Smoking
NBC Bay Area - June 1, 2012

Outdoor areas at restaurants and bars off-limits for Sonoma County smokers. ... Restaurants, bars forced to ban smoking in outdoor areas ... Smoking is already banned in common areas of apartment complexes, county-owned properties, and ...

In Our View: Ban Smoking in County Parks
The Columbian - April 27, 2012

Steve Stuart and Tom Mielke still don’t get it. The two Clark County commissioners just can’t bring themselves to ban smoking in county parks.Oh, they’re “getting it” when it comes to political points from some folks who praise them for supposedly upholding smokers’ rights. But here’s what erodes their credibility as they acknowledge that applause: By continuing to heap confusing details and detailed regulations upon smokers in parks, the two commissioners have done everything BUT ban smoking in county parks. Here’s what they were up to earlier this week: …

Consumer group not lovin' smoke at California McDonald's
Thomson Reuters , 2011-09-23

A consumer advocacy organization has sued McDonald's, alleging the fast-food chain has violated California law by permitting smoking in outdoor areas without warning its customers or employees of secondhand-smoke exposure. ...

Cuomo bans smoking on LIRR platforms
Newsday (subscription) (blog) - Yancey Roy - August 15, 2011

The ban applies to the Long Island Railroad and Metro North. Smoking is already banned at outdoor New York City subway platforms. In approving the bill, ...

Cambridge moves toward outdoor smoking ban
Wicked Local (MA), 2011-01-11
Brian P. Nanos Wicked Local Cambridge

Cambridge is taking more steps toward banning smoking in public places.

Public Health Officer Claude-Alix Jacob said in a memo to City Council that the city’s Public Health Department is looking to create a working group that would explore issues involved when cities ban smoking in public parks, beaches and other places.

According to his memo, which was written Dec. 14, the group would look at outdoor smoking bans throughout the country and the scientific literature on the health impact of such bans. It would also consider specific attributes of Cambridge’s public places, the feasibility of enforcing a ban and the feasibility of an outreach campaign that would precede enforcement ...

NY village bans smoking on public sidewalks
Wall Street Journal - January 5, 2011

AP GREAT NECK, NY ­ A tiny village on Long Island's "gold coast" is banning smoking on public sidewalks. The Great Neck village board approved the ban at a ...

Smoking ban in Great Neck Village
Newsday - Gary Dymski - January 5, 2011

The Great Neck Park District recently banned smoking in its parks. Village attorney Stephen G. Limmer said Wednesday the smoking ban "will take some time" ...

Smoking in Outdoor Areas Increases Health Risk
TopNews United States - Amit Pathania - August 4, 2010

"This research supports smoking bans in areas where people may spend extended periods of time, such as outdoor eating and drinking venues", she said.

New City of Ithaca outdoor smoking rules start Aug. 1
Ithaca (NY) Journal, 2010-07-24
Krisy Gashler

But the truth is, particularly on public property, the signs are just requests.

Starting next Saturday, in areas throughout the city, the request will no longer be optional. The City of Ithaca's much-discussed outdoor smoking regulations go into effect Aug. 1.

The ordinance states that someone smoking in a smoke-free area can be asked by a police officer to move or put out the tobacco product. If the smoker refuses, a first-offense ticket is $75. A second offense is $150 and a third offense is $250.

The change actually won't help deter the motivated smoker outside the human services building -- it only applies 25 feet around city buildings and schools. But it will prevent smoking in a host of other locations, including bus shelters, playgrounds, small city parks, all natural areas and around mobile vending carts. ...

Transit Authority To Consider Ban On Bus Stop Smoking
WXII The Triad - July 21, 2010

WINSTON-SALEM --
The Winston-Salem Transit Authority is discussing the possibility of banning smoking while under city bus stop shelters.

WSTA general manager Art Barnes said there haven't been many complaints, but there were enough to warrant an inquiry.

Barnes said he plans to present the issue to the full board next Thursday. ...

Supes approve smoking ban
The Daily Sound - Colby Frazier - June 18, 2010

Starting today, lighting up at most of Santa Barbara County’s 70 parks, beaches and trails will be a no-no.

In an effort to reduce litter, pollution and help ensure a clean-air environment exists for all park goers, the Board of Supervisors in May approved a smoking ban, which will go into effect today.

Smokers cringing at the thought of paying stiff fines, however, need not worry.

The main thrust of enforcing the ban, explained Michele Mickiewicz, a spokeswoman for the Public Health Department, is education.

“The approach that we’re using isn’t really punitive,” she said. “The signs are the primary driver.”

By the end of this month, Mickiewicz said signs will be posted at all of the county’s parks and beaches, with the exception of Cachuma Lake and Jalama Beach, where overnight camping is allowed and smoking will be permitted.

In addition to the signs, county officials will attempt to educate the public about the ban through bilingual newspaper and radio advertisements throughout the summer. ...

Community Partnerships Launch 'Tobacco Free Outdoors'
PR Newswire (press release) - June 17, 2010

ALBANY, N.Y., June 17 /PRNewswire/ -- Today, Community Partnerships for a Tobacco Free New York launched a campaign to educate New Yorkers about the benefits of tobacco free outdoor recreational areas. The campaign raises awareness of the environmental impact of tobacco litter, dangers of secondhand smoke and influence on children when tobacco use is not restricted.

(Photo: http://photos.prnewswire.com/prnh/20100617/NY22868)

(Photo: http://www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20100617/NY22868)

Tobacco litter is poisonous to children and wildlife. Discarded cigarette butts are the most common form of litter. Studies show they are toxic, slow to decompose, and costly to remove. Cigarette butts have been found in the stomachs of fish, whales, birds and other marine animals and can cause digestive blockages. Children routinely pick them up and try to place in their mouths.

"The Community Partnership has designed a paid media campaign to educate communities about why we need to adopt more tobacco free outdoor policies," said Susan Kennedy, CP Media Project Coordinator. "Family recreation for children should not mean having to play among cigarette butts or being exposed to secondhand smoke. ...

Starbucks snuffing out smoking outdoors
Marysville (CA) Appeal-Democrat, 2010-06-03
Ashley Gebb/Appeal-Democrat

A tall nonfat caramel macchiato with extra foam, please. Just hold the smoke.

Starting Monday, Starbucks customers are welcome to sit outside and sip a while ­ as long as they don't light up. The international coffee giant is extending its ban on indoor smoking to outdoor patios and dining areas in California. …

Veto disappoints backers of Calif. smoking ban
The Associated Press - Samantha Young - May 4, 2010

SACRAMENTO, Calif. — Advocates of a bill that would have banned smoking at all California state parks and beaches say they're disappointed in Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's decision to veto the measure.

"We're very dismayed to see the governor has not prioritized clean and healthy beaches, especially since our coast lines are a driving force to our California economy," said Angela Howe, an attorney for the nonprofit Surfrider Foundation, a San Clemente-based environmental organization.

The foundation had hoped Schwarzenegger would follow a 2008 recommendation by the California Ocean Protection Council to ban smoking at all state beaches to help reduce polluting marine debris.

But the cigar-smoking Schwarzenegger vetoed legislation that would have done that Monday, saying the bill crossed the line of government intrusion.

In a letter to California senators, the governor said state parks and local governments were already permitted to ban smoking on a case-by-case basis.

"There is something inherently uncomfortable about the idea of the state encroaching in such a broad manner on the people of California," Schwarzenegger wrote. ...

SLO to ban smoking in public areas
San Luis Obispo Tribune - Cynthia Lambert - April 7, 2010

Smoking will soon be banned from nearly all areas open to the public in San Luis Obispo, the City Council voted 4-1 Tuesday night.

Under the new law, which would be effective May 20 after it is given final approval at the council’s April 20 meeting, smoking would be prohibited in indoor and outdoor areas frequented by the public, including sidewalks, parking garages, bars, restaurants, stores, stadiums, playgrounds and transit centers.

Lighting up in outdoor areas would be banned in areas that are within 20 feet of indoor areas. ...

A Closer Look / Outdoor smoking bans
The research shows that secondhand smoke is unhealthful. But those conclusions are based on smoke-filled indoor environments. The consequences for outdoor settings are less clear.
Los Angeles Times, 2010-04-05
Jill U. Adams Special to the Los Angeles Times

...But, says Stanton Glantz, who directs the Center for Tobacco Control Research and Education at UC San Francisco, "a cigarette is like a little toxic waste dump on fire. If you're upwind of it, you don't have much effect. But if you happen to be in the plume -- or you're congregating around a doorway -- you can get quite high levels of exposure."

Cigarette smoke contains hundreds of chemicals, including benzene, carbon monoxide and nicotine, many of them known carcinogens. Fine particulate matter within smoke can carry those chemicals deep into the lungs, Glantz says.

Here's a closer look at the health effects of secondhand smoke. . . .

Calif. considers smoking ban at all state parks
Seattle Times, March 18, 2010

SACRAMENTO, Calif. —
California lawmakers on Thursday will consider what is believed to be the nation's most far-reaching smoking ban in state parks as a way to get unsightly cigarette butts off the beach, eliminate second-hand smoke and reduce the threat of wildfires.

Maine banned smoking at its state beaches last year, but groups that track such legislation say no state prohibits lighting up throughout its entire park system, as the California bill proposes.

Under a legislative compromise, campsites and parking areas will be exempted from the ban.

"It is very clear that the garbage that is created as a result of smoking on beaches - butts and wrappers - are polluting our water," Democratic state Sen. Jenny Oropeza of Long Beach, the bill's author, said in an interview. "In terms of the state park system, we have a major fire hazard when cigarettes are smoked in parks." ...

S.F. supervisors vote to get tougher on smoking
San Francisco Chronicle - Rachel Gordon - March 10, 2010

Smoking soon will be snuffed out at sidewalk cafes, restaurant patios, movie and ATM lines, bingo halls and the common areas of housing complexes.

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors voted Tuesday to extend smoking restrictions to those places, along with lighting up near doorways and windows of offices, shops and restaurants. It already is illegal to smoke in offices and commercial establishments that don't have a legally designated smoking area.

"This legislation will protect thousands of San Franciscans from secondhand smoke," said Supervisor Eric Mar, chief sponsor of the legislation. ...

RC widens smoking ban
Contra Costa Times - Wendy Leung - March 4, 2010

RANCHO CUCAMONGA - Smoking and waiting in lines do not mix, according to the City Council, which gave initial approval on Wednesday to an ordinance that prohibits tobacco use in transit stops and outdoor service lines.
The ordinance, expected to go into effect mid-April, will prohibit smoking within 20 feet of bus stops, train stations and lines for services such as ATMs and theaters.

Fabian Villenas of the city manager's office said people waiting in lines are a captive audience.

"If you're in line and an individual lights a cigarette, it's difficult to remove yourself from the second-hand smoke," Villenas said.

Under the leadership of Mayor Don Kurth, the city has been studying anti-smoking legislation since 2007.

In January 2008, the city passed an ordinance that banned smoking at city-owned properties such as public parks, Victoria Gardens Cultural Center and City Hall. Since then, the city manager's office has continued to study further restrictions.

The smoking ban at transit stops and service lines is a less stringent measure compared to bans that would affect sidewalks, apartments and outdoor dining areas. More stringent bans were considered but did not receive approval from a City Council majority.

Once the ordinance affecting transit stops and service lines goes into effect, violators could face a fine of $100 for first violation, $200 for second violation and $500 for additional violations. ...

Seattle parks chief relaxes smoking ban to a 25-foot rule
Seattle (WA) Times, 2010-02-19
Erik Lacitis Seattle Times staff reporter

That regulation totally banning smoking in Seattle parks? Never mind about the "totally" part. Just smoke, chew or engage in "other tobacco use" 25 feet away from other park patrons, said Parks Superintendent Timothy Gallagher in a news release issued late Thursday afternoon. If that sounds like backtracking, it is. . . .

It seems public comments that railed against the new rule worked.

Gallagher wasn't available to personally make a statement on the matter on Thursday because on Monday he went skiing in Oregon, and he won't be back at work until next Monday, said Parks spokeswoman Dewey Potter.

Potter said she didn't know where in Oregon Gallagher was, but apparently he learned the extent of the public reaction via an Internet or phone connection.
A story about Gallagher's decision, announced Wednesday, to impose a total smoking ban in Seattle parks had 344 comments -- most of them negative -- by 6 p.m. Thursday on seattletimes.com ...

Superintendent bans tobacco in Seattle parks
Seattle Parks Superintendent Timothy Gallagher banned smoking and chewing tobacco in Seattle parks, overruling an advisory board that last week voted against it.
Seattle (WA) Times, 2010-02-18
Emily Heffter Seattle Times staff reporter

Seattle Parks Superintendent Timothy Gallagher announced a ban on tobacco in Seattle parks Wednesday, overruling an advisory board that last week voted against it.

His ruling put an end to the public debate over whether people should be allowed to smoke and chew in Seattle's parks. In the end, Gallagher wrote in a memo, the ban was a health issue.

The ban aims to protect park users from secondhand smoke and cut down on litter caused by cigarette butts. It was also spurred by concerns that smokers set a poor example for children.

"The negative health effects of tobacco are well documented," Gallagher wrote. "As an agency that has a fundamental mission to support the health and well-being of Seattle residents, it is appropriate and beneficial to prohibit the use of tobacco products at parks and park facilities."

The ban takes effect April 1.

Gallagher's decision is within his authority as parks superintendent, but the Seattle City Council could pass an ordinance to overrule it. ...

NH Lawmakers Weigh Smoking Ban For Parks, Beaches
WBZ - February 11, 2010

CONCORD, N.H. (AP) ? State lawmakers are considering bills banning smoking at state parks and beaches.

One would ban smoking at the park's public gathering areas, such as the pavilions and restrooms.

At a legislative hearing Thursday, Ted Austin of the Parks and Recreation Department said his agency is not taking a position on the proposal but says it does get complaints about second-hand smoke.

But the acting head of the Cigar Association of New Hampshire, Ed Santamaria, said the bill would infringe on people's ability to enjoy themselves in the parks. ...

L.A. council extends smoking ban to outdoor cafes
Starting next year, restaurant patrons will be barred from lighting up within 10 feet of outdoor dining areas and within 40 feet of mobile food trucks. Violators faces fines of up to $250
Los Angeles Times, 2010-01-21
Maeve Reston

Smokers in Los Angeles lost another refuge Wednesday when the City Council unanimously approved a ban on lighting up in outdoor cafes, food courts and around the city's ubiquitous mobile food trucks.

With the move, city officials are following the lead of municipalities across California, including Burbank, Beverly Hills, Calabasas and Santa Monica, which already ban smoking in outdoor dining areas. California law bars smoking inside restaurants and bars.

The ordinance prohibits smoking within 10 feet of outdoor dining areas and within 40 feet of mobile food trucks. ...

Capitola's Proposed Smoking Ban Could Lead Nation
More Smoking Restrictions on Tap for 2010, Councilman Predicts
Mid-County Post (Capitola, CA), 2009-11-20
R.T. Sideman

When the statewide smoking ban took effect in 1999, Capitola's cigarette and cigar puffers were driven outdoors. But soon the outdoors -- or at least much of it -- may no longer be an option.

A proposal put forth by Capitola Councilman Dennis Norton would ban smoking on the Esplanade, the wharf, at city parks, the library, City Hall and the Stockton Avenue Bridge.

Beyond that, Norton also hinted at the possibility of a citywide ban in 2010 that would apply to all public outdoor spaces.

Citing concerns about secondhand smoke and piles of cigarette butt litter, Norton says it's time to take action. ...

The science behind moving smoking bans outside
- Wellness -
Time Magazine Blogs, 2009-11-19
Posted by Tiffany Sharples O'Callaghan

Reflecting on the existing scientific research on second hand smoke exposure outdoors, William Saletan of Slate.com sifts through the most relevant points from two major studies on the subject (the 2006 California Air Resources Board study, and a 2007 study from Stanford). Among the findings: outdoors, second hand smoke levels vary widely and quickly, depend on the individual's distance from a smoker (farther than 6.5 feet or 2 meters, generally reduces exposure to "background" levels), are influenced by how confined the outdoor space is (if there are walls or fences), and the concentration of smokers in a given area. The data, Saletan concludes, point to the need for a measured approach for crafting policy to reduce second hand smoke exposure outdoors. He writes:

"If you want to argue for parkwide smoking bans based on asthma or on an analogy to noise pollution, go ahead and make that case. But let's not cloud that debate by invoking the general harm of secondhand smoke. Studies of secondhand smoke have indeed moved outdoors. Their findings support restrictions on lighting up within a few feet of other people. But they don't warrant more than that."

A new study published in the November issue of the Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene may contribute to the debate. Researchers from the University of Georgia measured second hand smoke exposure among people sitting in the outdoor areas of bars and restaurants where indoor smoking was banned in the city of Athens, Georgia. . . .

generally speaking, hanging out in an outdoor smoking area exposes you to less second hand smoke than being in an indoor, confined space with smokers, and the more space you have between yourself and smokers, the lower levels of exposure you will have. So, this particular study doesn't ring the death knell for outdoor smoking. But, the researchers point out, wielding the official trump card of the public health argument:
Although the increment in cotinine concentrations and, thus, the [second hand smoke] exposure levels were relatively low at the sites of interest, the current view is that there is no level of personal exposure to [second hand smoke] that can be regarded as safe. This study demonstrates the ongoing exposure of nonsmokers to [second hand smoke] outside restaurants and bars, and the limitations of indoor smoking bans alone in protecting the public from exposure to [second hand smoke] outside these establishments.

In other words, the movement to ban smoking in outdoor spaces is here to stay.

Study raises concerns about outdoor second-hand smoke
ScienceDaily, 2009-11-19

Indoor smoking bans have forced smokers at bars and restaurants onto outdoor patios, but a new University of Georgia study in collaboration with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention suggests that these outdoor smoking areas might be creating a new health hazard.

The study, thought to be the first to assess levels of a nicotine byproduct known as cotinine in nonsmokers exposed to second-hand smoke outdoors, found levels up to 162 percent greater than in the control group. The results appear in the November issue of the Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene.

"Indoor smoking bans have helped to create more of these outdoor environments where people are exposed to secondhand smoke," said study co-author Luke Naeher, associate professor in the UGA College of Public Health. "We know from our previous study that there are measurable airborne levels of secondhand smoke in these environments, and we know from this study that we can measure internal exposure.

"Secondhand smoke contains several known carcinogens and the current thinking is that there is no safe level of exposure," he added. "So the levels that we are seeing are a potential public health issue."

Athens-Clarke County, Ga., enacted an indoor smoking ban in 2005, providing Naeher and his colleagues and ideal environment for their study. ...

Palm Desert City Council passes smoking restrictions
The Desert Sun - November 13, 2009

The Palm Desert City Council voted unanimously Thursday night to approve new restrictions on public smoking aimed at cutting down secondhand smoke in the city.

The measure most likely will not take effect until the new year, as it was the plan's first reading and the second reading and final vote is not likely until December.

Nevertheless, Thursday's 5-0 vote means all buildings and businesses in Palm Desert will have to keep smokers at least 20 feet from their main entrances. ...

Falmouth voters OK ban on beach smoking
Cape Cod (MA) Times, 2009-11-11
Aaron Gouveia

Voters at last night's town meeting gave a big thumbs down to those who like to light up on the town's public beaches.

Smoking is no longer allowed on any of the town's 11 public beaches, following a 128-60 vote that makes Falmouth the third community on the Cape to snuff out smoking on municipal beaches. Proponents of the ban cited litter in the form of errant cigarette butts in the sand, as well as the harm caused by secondhand smoke, as the main reasons to pass the smoking ban warrant item. . . .

In the end, a majority of town meeting voters said they were tired of "inconsiderate" people on the beach who refuse to move even after complaints and throw cigarette filters in the sand, where young children often find them while building sand castles.

Fremont to ban outdoor smoking at restaurants
Inside Bay Area, 2009-10-29

The closest thing to a smoking section for Fremont eateries soon will be the parking lot.

The City Council unanimously backed a new law Tuesday prohibiting restaurants from allowing smoking at outdoor tables.

The law, which is scheduled to go into effect in early December, puts Fremont on par with most East Bay cities, including Hayward, which already has banned outdoor smoking at restaurants, City Attorney Harvey Levine said. ...

Smoking ban in Ayer covers the great outdoors
Boston (MA) Globe, 2009-10-29

It was a recent trip to the park that finally did it.

Jason Mayo watched as a father pushed his child on a swing, cigarette clenched between his teeth. On every upswing, the child got a face full of exhaled smoke.

"We can't tell people how to parent,'' said Mayo, a member of the Ayer parks and recreation committee, which has banned smoking in the town's recreation areas. "But all the other kids around him were inhaling that cigarette too.''

As antismoking sentiment sweeps across the country, nonsmokers are taking back bars, restaurants, and workplaces, snuffing smoking out of its indoor havens. And now some of them are turning their sights on the great outdoors.

Holliston and Upton have enacted similar outdoor smoking bans. And in another example of the widespread public crackdown on smoking, Needham has outlawed the sale of cigarettes in pharmacies and Newton and Framingham are trying to do the same. ...

L.A. officials express support for smoking ban in outdoor dining areas
Los Angeles Times blogs, 2009-10-27

A Los Angeles City Council committee voiced support today for a ban on smoking in the city's outdoor dining areas, but ordered several changes to the ordinance before sending it to the full council for approval.

The council could take up the measure as early as next month.

City code already prohibits smoking in parks, farmers' markets and on city beaches, while state law bars customers from lighting up inside restaurants. Other cities have imposed far more restrictive bans; Calabasas, for instance, prohibits smoking in public areas.

The legislation authored by Councilmen Greig Smith and Dennis Zine would ban smoking within a 10-foot radius of outdoor dining areas. The proposed no-smoking area around mobile food trucks and food kiosks would extend for 40 feet.

Bars, private events and nightclubs serving customers older than 18 would be exempt. ...